The Harlequin Horizons Train Wreck Hitting Home
I'm not as outraged or incensed as many authors. No throwing tomatoes, please. It's just that self-publishing and vanity publishing have been around for years and years. Harlequin isn't driving the bandwagon, they merely jumped on it, a place where other large publishers have been for a while. If an author decides to self or vanity publish, they have many, many companies from which to choose. Self and vanity publishing is, in fact, widely accepted in some writing groups. I have attended the Southwest Society of Writers conference four times. Not only are book doctors and self publishing companies welcomed there and allowed to set up tables to distribute their literature, attendees can purchase an appointment with a book doctor or company rep for $15-25 (talk about a scam).
Not being outraged or incensed, however, doesn't mean I'm without a horribly bad taste in my mouth and a severe sense of disappointment and loss. But that loss is strictly personal. You see, this really is all about me.
I dreamed of having a career with Harlequin for years. Finally selling to them was one of the highlights of my life. I relived that joy with each new book contract, each new cover, each new review in Romantic Times. I made good money from Harlequin in 2009. I made as much money as some people, especially in this tough economy, earn in a year working forty hours a week. That ain't too shabby. I submitted three workshop proposals to RWA Nationals recently and for the first time, felt that I was truly qualified to be a speaker. I have three books coming out in 2010, a goal of mine for years. Most exciting, I arranged for my editor to come to my local chapter's conference in April of 2010.
And suddenly, the last week, all these good feelings, my sense of accomplishment, my joy and pride in my hard-earned writing career, have been tarnished, if not downright become meaningless. This didn't happen at first. No, it wasn't until a non-Harlequin author posted on a loop that she would never buy another Harlequin book again and our conference chair emailed me to ask if we should go ahead with having my editor at the conference since RWA removed Harlequin from their list of eligible publishers. Suddenly, I saw my career going down the toilet. I mean, let's be serious. Sales are everything. And the thought that Harlequin's vanity publishing program could ultimately affect my sales, my income and my career, hits about as close to home as you can get. That, more than a loathing of Harlequin's money-grubbing, preying on innocent writers business practices and my inability to enter the RITA next year with what I believe is my best Harlequin American ever, upsets me.
After several sleep deprived nights, I came to conclusion that I will do what's best for me and my writing career. That's the only reasonable course of action I can take. I will finish up my current contract with Harlequin because there is no way I will breach it. I will continue to write and submit non-Harlequin American proposals to other publishers, as I have been doing for the last couple years (my agent just sent one out about two weeks ago, and I've started working on a new one). I will also submit to Harlequin American again and sell to them as long as it makes sense career-wise and money-wise.
It's my fervent hope that Harlequin will cease with their vanity publishing division and that, after months of damage control, I will once again be thrilled and proud to be one of their authors. If not, I will survive, making the choices and decisions that are best for me in the long run.
Cathy Mc





